The OEM all-weather mats came with our 2018 as part of the Cold Weather Package, and they are fine. I've always been a "mats guy" rather than a "floor liner guy." I don't want to feel as though I'm driving a delivery truck, with my feet in buckets of plastic.The Jeep mats that came with my TH are close enough to Weatherguard for me. They're fairly high quality.
Nothing wrong with the Weathertech cargo liner. However, I ordered custom-cut cargo mats for both Cherokees from Lloyd Mats for two reasons: many more color options (I was able to order a pink one for my wife, although pink no longer seems to be an option), and a perfectly flat edge, instead of a raised, tray-like lip. I find that it's easier to slide things into the cargo compartment with the seats down if there's no barrier along the edge of the cargo mat.I just need the cargo liner. I'm surprised my optioned out TH didn't come with anything for the cargo compartment. I don't know how much shipping would be but Weatherguard is pretty proud of that one cargo mat at $115