That is very odd.. I will dig out the exact one I have in the garage later today and I will take a picture of the ends on both sides and you can see if it will help or not.I've been studying the picture you posted but it it looks like yours is quite a bit shorter & shaped differently. Mine is more oval at the ends where as yours looks like it has sharp angles. Mine is(was) one shade & nothing is recessed like yours seems to be. Mine is kinda embossed.
It's really strange how our rigs cans be the same year or one year difference & yet be so different in some areas. Another Jeeper (TH) tried to help me out as well. His was a 14 also, but his vanity cover was completely different. In fact his looked kinda like yours.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk