Rant time, since you asked
We love most of our Compass, its so comfortable and sharp-looking and when its all working its great, but have had so many reliability issues with it that we hoped were attributable to it being one of the very first of the MP series to roll off the assembly line and perhaps its Fiat roots and country of assembly, its lower price, etc. We perceived that the Cherokee KL would surely be much more solid and reliable since its assembled in the united states and its been in production since 2014, and 25% more expensive to boot. For the most part our assumptions were correct, the mature KL product is leaps better than our MP in every regard, but somehow it still ended up that our KL gave us a scare that we and two friends were going to be stranded in rural Wisconsin frigid weather at an AirBnB we had just checked out from and locked ourselves out of, and then happened a bunch more times that the Cherokee had to go to the dealership for almost a week over this stupid relay issue.
This may be only the first (major) strike for our KL, but we're more sensitive to issues because of how many weeks the MP has been in the shop for similarly aggravating failures that never should have happened. Its a brand frustration at this point. Buying the KL signified us extending a second chance to the Jeep brand to demonstrate to us that our poor experience with reliability in our MP is not representative of the brand as a whole. If this KL doesn't stand rock-solid for us to at least 5 years/100k miles then we likely give up.
We really, really don't enjoy being embarrassed by our Jeep vehicles. I hated it when the body control computer on our Compass would temporarily loose its mind and have to try to explain to passengers why they couldn't turn their heated seat off, or having the Uconnect freeze completely and loose control of the volume (but not have music stop playing, that has actually happened in the Compass and the Cherokee both...). Uconnect freezing while trying to navigate an unfamiliar city and get to a destination, resulting in a passenger having to quick load up maps on their phone to take over giving me directions while navigating heavy traffic, not cool. Having such a poorly designed ESS system in the Compass that passengers ask "whats wrong with your car?" when it does an autostop event and the bargain-bin oil-gobbling 2.4 stumbles to a stop, and then inexplicably chudders back to life only one second later destroying any semblance of "gas saving" that the feature is supposed to do (that I "fixed" by disabling the ESS permanently). To add to that pile we
really didn't enjoy loading up two of our friends and all our gear after a nice weekend of skiing in Wisconsin and having our 2020 KL take 4 uncomfortable restart attempts to stay running in -8 degree weather, and then for it to say running finally but have the dash lit up like a christmas tree with warning lights and error messages so having to explain to them "Ok, its running, but I'm going to have to shut it off and clear these error codes with my ODBII scanner otherwise I won't have the use of cruise control for the entire 500 mile trip home..."
It's just not fun having these cars and not being able to give them a glowing review and recommendation when friend's and family comment on the sharp looks and styling. We feel we have to be honest with people. Friends have asked to test drive my Compass because they were thinking about buying one but after giving them my honest recollection of my experience they end up going with a GMC Terrain or a Subaru or something else, and I can't blame them.
We don't like the looks/styling or comfort level of Hondas but we've owned two of those from new (2011 and 2016 models) that sailed to 100k miles so effortlessly with nothing but oil and tire changes, and they
always started at any temperature. We have a beater CRV in the driveway that as of today has 300,944 miles on it, all original, with a nasty 6 or 7 year-old walmart everstart battery in it hardly bigger than my lawn mower battery, and event THAT miserable old clunker started the other week at -24 below in one try while our beautiful new 2020 Cherokee was doing the start/stall/error messages and check engine light nonsense. That is flat out unacceptable. Once, maybe, as a fluke but what I'm saying is our MP Compass has blown most of our trust in overall Jeep brand to start with so whats left of our trust will be easily broken if our KL ends up in the shop for anything stupid one or two more times. We bought the Cherokee because we still want to build that trust in the Jeep brand but we need the KL to make up for the MP.
Worth adding to that also, the Ford Bronco series were still pretty much unheard of/too far out on the horizon at the time that we were shopping so there was still nothing that really competed very hard with the Cherokee or the Wrangler on the market at the time. Ford has purpose-built the Bronco series to be all-out Jeep killers, the full-size Bronco blows the Wrangler away on specs and intelligent design and the smaller Bronco Sport is clearly gunning for the Cherokee and Compass both. We want the rugged, capable vehicles to support an adventure-oriented lifestyle but we also want rock-solid reliability. To us this is the one "pass" that our KL is going to get. "Bad luck with a batch of relays", whatever, something like that can happen
once, but that had better be the end of it or most likely we will become Ford/Toyota/Honda people out of sheer frustration.