I almost bought a Forester XT right before I stopped at a local Jeep dealer to take a look at the Cherokee. My wife has a Subaru and it has been a fantastic car (except for the brakes) so I was ready to just jump in on another Subaru. I didn't care for the seats, the CVT, or the requirement for premium fuel on the XT model which is why I stopped next door at the Jeep dealer. The moment I test drove a V6 Cherokee I knew I had to have one.
2016 Jeep Cherokee vs. 2016 Subaru Forester: Which Is Better?
2
Continuing its series of head to head comparisons, Autotrader pits the 2016 Cherokee against the 2016 Forester. While I am not a fan of Subarus, and the choice would be easy for me, I figure that a lot of people here had this very dilemma, so this will make for some interesting reading. Here are the key excerpts and the link:
![]()
![]()
Reliability
According to experts at Consumer Reports, the Subaru Forester offers above average reliability. The opposite is true of the Jeep Cherokee, whose reliability is rated as below average. When it comes to warranty length, both crossovers offer the same coverage of 3 years or 36,000 miles of bumper-to-bumper protection, plus 5 years or 60,000 miles of powertrain coverage. Considering the differences in reliability scores, the Forester easily wins this category.
Fuel Economy
...If you're interested in fuel economy, the Forester is the winner, as it offers slightly better gas mileage ratings with both base-level and optional engines. However, the Cherokee's numbers come pretty close to the Subaru's, and it offers more power.
Safety
In crash tests carried out by the federal government's National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, both the Jeep Cherokee and the Subaru Forester earned a perfect 5-star overall rating. In testing performed by the nonprofit Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), only the Forester earned the firm's coveted Top Safety Pick+ rating, while the Cherokee didn't qualify due to a troubling Marginal score in the challenging front small-overlap test.
As for safety features, both the Cherokee and the Forester offer just about everything you can imagine, including forward-collision alert with automatic braking, adaptive cruise control, lane-departure warning, a blind spot monitoring system and rear cross-traffic alert. The Cherokee has a few extras, however, like an available automated parking system and automatic high beams.
Technology
....The Cherokee is undoubtedly the technology leader in this segment. In addition to offering Uconnect, the best infotainment system on the market (with an 8.4-in touchscreen, to boot), the Cherokee touts an available automated parking system, a remote starter, ventilated front seats, automatic high beams and lane-keep assist.
While the Forester is hardly a dinosaur when it comes to gadgets and features, the Cherokee is the clear winner here.
Driving Experience
...As for ride quality, both the Cherokee and the Forester deliver about what you'd expect: a comfortable ride, but not a luxurious one. We think the Cherokee offers more ride comfort than the Forester. Handling, however, goes to the Subaru, though neither of these models is race-car agile.
Autotraders Choice
Our pick? For a larger vehicle with a more comfortable ride and more available power, you'll want the Cherokee. The Forester is smaller, leaner and more maneuverable.
http://www.autotrader.com/car-revie...s-2016-subaru-forester-which-is-better-246529
Reliability
According to experts at Consumer Reports, the Subaru Forester offers above average reliability. The opposite is true of the Jeep Cherokee, whose reliability is rated as below average. When it comes to warranty length, both crossovers offer the same coverage of 3 years or 36,000 miles of bumper-to-bumper protection, plus 5 years or 60,000 miles of powertrain coverage. Considering the differences in reliability scores, the Forester easily wins this category.
Fuel Economy
...If you're interested in fuel economy, the Forester is the winner, as it offers slightly better gas mileage ratings with both base-level and optional engines. However, the Cherokee's numbers come pretty close to the Subaru's, and it offers more power.
Safety
In crash tests carried out by the federal government's National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, both the Jeep Cherokee and the Subaru Forester earned a perfect 5-star overall rating. In testing performed by the nonprofit Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), only the Forester earned the firm's coveted Top Safety Pick+ rating, while the Cherokee didn't qualify due to a troubling Marginal score in the challenging front small-overlap test.
As for safety features, both the Cherokee and the Forester offer just about everything you can imagine, including forward-collision alert with automatic braking, adaptive cruise control, lane-departure warning, a blind spot monitoring system and rear cross-traffic alert. The Cherokee has a few extras, however, like an available automated parking system and automatic high beams.
Technology
....The Cherokee is undoubtedly the technology leader in this segment. In addition to offering Uconnect, the best infotainment system on the market (with an 8.4-in touchscreen, to boot), the Cherokee touts an available automated parking system, a remote starter, ventilated front seats, automatic high beams and lane-keep assist.
While the Forester is hardly a dinosaur when it comes to gadgets and features, the Cherokee is the clear winner here.
Driving Experience
...As for ride quality, both the Cherokee and the Forester deliver about what you'd expect: a comfortable ride, but not a luxurious one. We think the Cherokee offers more ride comfort than the Forester. Handling, however, goes to the Subaru, though neither of these models is race-car agile.
Autotraders Choice
Our pick? For a larger vehicle with a more comfortable ride and more available power, you'll want the Cherokee. The Forester is smaller, leaner and more maneuverable.
http://www.autotrader.com/car-revie...s-2016-subaru-forester-which-is-better-246529
21 - 31 of 31 Posts
Wow are you guys easy on this forum...? What in the heck is a Forester...I thought it was I guy that cut trees! Go to real Jeep forum like the Wrangler forum, these are real Jeep guys! I switched from a JKU Sahara to a TrailHawk, now wife and I are twins (yuk) except colors! The JKU forum pretty much disbanded me. Jeez comparing any Jeep to anything is like death before dishonor.
I love MY new TH, do I miss the JKU Sahara, you bet!!!! Do I wish I had it back...not fully sure yet??? Just read on the forum about the TH 4wd overheating in the sand and shutting down? Sand is almost all I off road in, the wife's TH has never done that...hope it's not a normal happening?
Ride safe, break nothin' and remind me again, what's a Forester? Jeeps Rule.
I love MY new TH, do I miss the JKU Sahara, you bet!!!! Do I wish I had it back...not fully sure yet??? Just read on the forum about the TH 4wd overheating in the sand and shutting down? Sand is almost all I off road in, the wife's TH has never done that...hope it's not a normal happening?
Ride safe, break nothin' and remind me again, what's a Forester? Jeeps Rule.
21 - 31 of 31 Posts
